Am I Tone Deaf? What Tone Deafness Really Means | Sage Music®
+1 (833) 537-0680

Am I Tone Deaf?

Do you avoid singing in front of others? Have your friends told you that you can’t sing, or that you’re tone deaf?

If you believe you are tone deaf, you will find yourself in similar company. In one music teacher’s survey of 359 students and staff at a UK school, 34% said they can’t sing. A survey of university students found that up to 17% believe they are tone deaf.

These groups of people often avoid trying to learn music because they feel like they have no talent for music or singing.

However, the number of people who are actually tone deaf is closer to 1.5%. That means that 10 times as many people believe that they are tone deaf than they really are. Most people who think they can’t sing don’t have amusia. They just haven’t learned how yet.

Based on these stats, if you think you are tone deaf, you are probably not.

Why do so many articles say 4% of people are tone deaf?

You may see other articles say 4% of the population has amusia, but that number was based on a single test from 1980. Newer research has superseded that study with a larger sample of 20,000 people and objective tests. It determined that the actual prevalence of amusia is 1.5% of the population. An even more recent study of 383 Colombian students put that number even lower, at 0.52%. The differences may come from how amusia is defined in the study, and the populations studied.

Understanding Tone Deafness

When a person is tone deaf, also called having amusia, they are less able to recognize differences in pitch. Those with amusia are less able to perceive and produce sounds of the correct pitch compared to those without, according to research by Loui and others.

Brain scans of people with amusia revealed that there is a weaker connection between the part of their brains that process sounds and the part of their brains that operate higher-level thinking. Researchers are still debating whether the hearing areas themselves also work differently.

Ready to learn if you are really tone deaf?
Take the Sage Music tone deaf test.

Get instant results in less than 5 minutes. No sign up required.

Determining If You’re Tone Deaf

More often, when people complain of being tone deaf, it’s actually because they can’t sing what they do hear. That’s not a problem of being tone deaf; it’s that they have trouble performing the complex work of singing. They will hear a sound, but not know how to reproduce it.

On the other hand, in Loui’s small lab study, people with amusia could hum whether a pitch went up or down about as well as anyone else, but the notes themselves were far less accurate, which is why they still sound out of tune.

As long as you do not have true amusia, this ability to match pitch can be learned. We help people do this all the time.

The best way to determine if you are tone deaf is to take a test. We have a simple free tone deaf test that you can take. Our quiz will give you a general idea of whether you may or may not have amusia. There are a few things which make our test different from others. First, it is designed to be taken on the internet, with the prevalence of mobile devices and absence of lab quality speakers. Secondly, it will adapt to the test taker’s vocal range.

However, we cannot diagnose you with tone deafness. For a clinical diagnosis of congenital amusia, you would need to take the gold standard assessment in a clinical setting, which is the Montreal Battery of Evaluation of Amusia.

Early indicators that you are or are not tone deaf

Family History

It is likely that tone deafness is hereditary. According to the same 2017 study (Peretz and Vuvan), 46% of the parents, siblings, and children of amusics had it, too. If you have immediate family members with amusia, you are more likely to have it. If no one in your family has amusia, you are less likely to have it.

Enjoyment

Amusics often describe music as a noisy din, or may avoid situations where music is present. If you find yourself avoiding music, you are more likely to have tone-deafness. On the other hand, if you do enjoy music, you are less likely to have amusia.

Recognition

Those with amusia often have difficulty recognizing popular songs in their own culture. Do you remember or recognize songs? If so, you are probably not tone deaf.

How Music Lessons Can Help

It’s very rare to be unable to match pitch or to be tone deaf. At Sage Music®, we’ve seen more than 7,833 students, and not one has been unable to match pitch. This seems unusual. If 1.5% of the population is tone deaf, you would expect that 1.5% of our students would have it, too. However, people with amusia tend to describe music as a noisy din, or avoid places with music. It is our assumption that people who truly have amusia simply are not pursuing music, which is why they don’t show up in our student population.

If you are interested in music, that is a sign that you may not be tone-deaf. And if that is the case, music lessons can certainly help, because you more likely have difficulty with the mechanics of singing.

Not being able to match pitch is frustrating, and you probably don’t enjoy singing in front of people. But music lessons can help.

If you do have amusia, however, musical training will probably not fix the issue according to Peretz and Vuvan.

By learning how to place the vocal apparatus, your mouth, your head, and how to breathe and support the pitch, you can get better at matching pitch. Your singing skills will improve and a talented vocal teacher can select pieces that help to develop your singing and your voice.

Even if you’d rather play an instrument than sing, singing lessons are worth considering. Learning to sing what you see on the page helps instrumentalists learn songs faster and catch wrong notes and rhythms on their own.

Taking music lessons is a great way to learn to match pitch. It will take some work on your part, but with a teacher’s help, you can improve your singing abilities. You can also learn to sing online if you aren’t able to come in to take lessons at Sage Music. Using a digital tuner and singing scales with a tuner can help you to gain better control over your vocal pitch. (Although, digital tuners will not help you sing pure intervals, and can sometimes be misleading.)

The Ultimate Goal: To Enjoy Music

Chances are that you aren’t actually tone deaf, but even if you do have amusia, you can still enjoy music. People who have amusia can’t always identify the emotional content of a piece of music, and their ability to verbalize those emotions found in music is sometimes limited. However, people with amusia can identify the emotional intensity contained in music.

If you want to learn to enjoy music more, we’d be happy to help you here at Sage Music. All of our music teachers are professionals, employed and trained by Sage Music to help you play the music you love and meet your goals. We offer singing lessons in San Antonio, online, and in New York.

Looking for help matching pitch? We can help you sing the songs you love.
Share this:

Related

 ⋅  0 comments have been posted.
Login or sign up to post comments.